- The IMO’s Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) framework, which came into force in January 2023, is now producing real commercial consequences for shipping: vessels rated D or E face mandatory Corrective Action Plans, and charterers are increasingly specifying minimum CII ratings in tender requirements, creating a two-tier market between clean and dirty ships.
- The Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (EEXI) — a one-time compliance certification requirement — has been met by most vessels through engine power limitation (EPL), a controversial approach that reduces paper emissions intensity but does not improve actual fuel efficiency, raising questions about the framework’s real-world effectiveness.
- The economics of green retrofits — wind-assisted propulsion (Flettner rotors, rigid sails, kite systems), shaft generator optimisation, hull air lubrication, and propeller improvements — are increasingly compelling for vessels with 10+ years of remaining service life, with payback periods shortening as fuel costs rise and CII regulatory pressure intensifies.
The IMO Regulatory Framework: What’s Actually Required
The IMO’s short-term climate measures for existing ships — adopted in June 2021 as amendments to MARPOL Annex VI — comprise two distinct but related requirements: the Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (EEXI) and the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII). Understanding the difference between these two requirements is essential for making sense of the commercial dynamics currently playing out in the shipping market.
The EEXI is a one-time technical certification requirement. Each vessel must demonstrate that its EEXI value — essentially a calculation of its design energy efficiency based on engine power, speed, and cargo capacity — meets a required standard based on ship type and size. Vessels that don’t meet the standard on a technical basis must be modified to comply. The modification options include engine power limitation (reducing the maximum allowed power output), installation of energy-saving devices, or (rarely) major propulsion system modifications.
The CII is an operational performance metric. Every year, vessels of 5,000 GT and above must calculate their actual CII — based on the CO2 emitted during the year divided by a capacity-distance measure that combines deadweight tonnes and nautical miles travelled. This operational CII is then compared to a required reference value (based on ship type and size), and vessels are rated A through E based on how they perform relative to the requirement. The reference values become more stringent by a small percentage each year, meaning that a vessel which is C-rated today may become D or E-rated in future years without any improvement in its actual emissions — the reference simply moves past it.
The EEXI Compliance Reality: EPL and Its Critics
Engine power limitation — the predominant method used to achieve EEXI compliance — has attracted significant criticism from environmental groups and some within the industry. The logic of EPL is superficially coherent: if you restrict the maximum power output of an engine, the vessel’s technical EEXI calculation improves because the denominator in the calculation (transport work) increases relative to the numerator (design energy consumption). In reality, most vessels rarely operate at their full installed power, particularly when slow steaming — so applying a formal EPL through an engine management system change often doesn’t change how the vessel actually operates in practice.
The EPL approach achieves paper compliance without necessarily achieving real emissions reduction — a distinction that matters considerably if the goal is to actually improve the climate performance of the world fleet rather than to tick a regulatory box. The IMO has been aware of this criticism, and the tightening of CII reference values over time is intended to ensure that the operational metric (CII) eventually forces genuine improvement even if the technical metric (EEXI) was met through paper measures.
For shipowners and operators, the practical consequence of EEXI compliance is that the regulatory requirement has been met for the vast majority of the trading fleet, and the attention has shifted to CII management as the ongoing compliance challenge. A vessel that achieved EEXI compliance through EPL may find that its actual CII performance is challenging if its operational energy efficiency doesn’t improve alongside the tightening reference values.
CII in Practice: Commercial Differentiation Is Real
The CII framework has been in place for three rating cycles now (2023, 2024, 2025), and the commercial consequences are becoming visible. Major charterers — commodity traders, oil majors chartering crude tankers, container shipping lines chartering feeders — are incorporating CII ratings into their vessel procurement processes. BP, Shell, TotalEnergies, and others have published requirements that vessels chartered for their programmes should achieve minimum CII ratings, typically A or B, and some are applying freight premium frameworks that pay higher rates for better CII-rated vessels.
The financial impact is still modest relative to the overall freight market, but the direction is established. Vessels rated D or E face mandatory Corrective Action Plans that must be submitted to their flag administration, and the reputational and commercial consequences of poor CII ratings are beginning to affect asset values. In the second-hand vessel market, CII ratings are increasingly cited alongside age, drydock history, and classification society status as commercial factors in sale price negotiations.
The banking and insurance community is also incorporating CII and sustainability metrics into their frameworks. Several major ship finance banks have introduced sustainability-linked loan terms that provide preferential interest rates for vessels achieving minimum CII or sustainability performance standards. The direction is clear: the cost of capital for poor environmental performers is rising, and the cost for good performers is falling.
Wind-Assisted Propulsion: The Oldest Technology Gets a Second Wind
Among the energy-saving technologies being evaluated and deployed to improve CII ratings, wind-assisted propulsion has attracted the most attention from a technology perspective — and perhaps the most scepticism from hardened shipping professionals. The idea of putting sails on commercial ships conjures images of the pre-steam era, but the technology being deployed in 2026 is far removed from conventional sail.
Flettner rotors — large, rotating cylinders that exploit the Magnus Effect (the same principle that makes a spinning tennis ball curve) to generate thrust when wind flows across them — have been commercially deployed on several vessels. Norsepower’s Rotor Sail products have been installed on RoRo vessels, tankers, and bulk carriers operated by Maersk, Viking Line, and others. The fuel savings documented in operational studies range from 5% to 30% depending on route, vessel type, and wind conditions — a wide range that reflects the fundamentally variable nature of wind-assisted propulsion on routes with varying wind conditions.
Rigid wing sails — essentially large aircraft wings mounted vertically on deck — are being commercialised by Oceanbird (Wallenius Marine) and others. Kite systems — large semi-rigid kites flown several hundred metres above the vessel on a tow line, exploiting stronger and more consistent winds at altitude — have been developed by Airseas (an Airbus subsidiary) and Yara Marine Technologies. Each approach has its optimal application: Flettner rotors suit vessels with open deck space and consistent broad-reach wind conditions; rigid sails are better for complex manoeuvring environments; kites suit long ocean crossings on favourable routes.
Hull and Propulsion Efficiency: The Low-Hanging Fruit
Beyond wind assistance, a range of proven technologies address hull and propulsion efficiency without the novelty factor. Air lubrication systems — which pump a layer of micro-bubbles along the hull bottom, reducing frictional resistance between hull and water — are offered by Silverstream Technologies (Marine Air Film System), Mitsubishi (MALS system), and others. The energy savings are claimed at 5-10% for large vessels, with payback periods typically 3-5 years at current fuel prices.
Propeller optimisation — replacing existing propellers with more efficient designs or installing wake equalising duct and flow-improving devices (fins, nozzles) that improve the quality of water flow into the propeller — is one of the most cost-effective retrofits available. A new propeller designed for the vessel’s actual operating profile (as opposed to the design profile from original build) can deliver 3-8% fuel savings with a payback period of under two years in some cases.
Shaft generators — which allow the ship’s main engine to generate electricity for the hotel load (accommodation, navigation, pumps) when at sea, eliminating the need for auxiliary diesel generators — improve overall system efficiency and reduce auxiliary fuel consumption. This is a particularly valuable retrofit for vessels with high auxiliary power demands, such as tankers with deck machinery and LNG carriers with boil-off gas management systems.
Slow Steaming: The Operational Lever That Needs No Capital
The most immediately impactful tool for improving CII ratings requires no capital investment: slow steaming. Fuel consumption scales approximately with the cube of speed — reducing a vessel’s speed by 10% reduces fuel consumption by approximately 27%. This relationship means that operational speed management is the single most powerful variable in the CII calculation, and charterers and operators have strong incentives to maintain the slowest speed consistent with schedule requirements.
The widespread adoption of slow steaming since 2008 has been the industry’s most significant fuel efficiency improvement, driven initially by the cost incentive of high fuel prices and subsequently reinforced by the CII regime. The practical limit is schedule requirements — customers need cargo to arrive on time, and routes with rigid scheduling constraints (liner trades, time-sensitive cargo) can’t always accommodate the slowest possible speed.
The combination of slow steaming, hull efficiency improvements, and wind assistance creates a multi-lever approach to CII management that is accessible to most vessel operators without major capital investment. For vessels with 10-15 years of remaining service life, the investment case for comprehensive retrofit programmes is increasingly compelling — the combination of fuel savings and CII rating improvement delivers both operating cost reduction and commercial positioning benefits that together justify the capital outlay in most current market scenarios.

